Friday, January 6, 2017

Pushover (1954)

July 30, 1954, release date
Directed by Richard Quine
Screenplay by Roy Huggins
Based on the novels The Night Watch by Thomas Walsh and Rafferty by Bill S. Ballinger
Music by Arthur Morton
Edited by Jerome Thoms
Cinematography by Lester White

Fred MacMurray as Paul Sheridan
Philip Carey as Rick McAllister
Kim Novak as Lona McLane
Dorothy Malone as Ann Stewart
E. G. Marshall as Lieutenant Carl Eckstrom
Allen Nourse as Paddy Dolan
Phil Chambers as Briggs
Alan Dexter as Fine
Robert Stevenson as Billings
Don C. Harvey as Peters
Paul Richards as Harry Wheeler
Ann Morriss as Ellen Burnett

Distributed by Columbia Pictures

Pushover opens with a bank heist, and the setup of the opening sequence reminds me of the opening sequences in The Friends of Eddie Coyle and The Town. In Pushover, the opening credits appear while one of the robbers sits down inside the bank with his gun ready to guard the bank door. As the employees enter the bank to start their workday, they become hostages. The bank manager and one other employee are forced to open the bank’s vault for two of the thieves. The bank security guard goes for one of the thieves who is holding the remaining employees at gunpoint, and the guard is shot and killed by a thief coming out of the bank vault.

(This blog post about Pushover contains spoilers.)

The plot then switches to a seemingly unrelated plot thread that viewers don’t yet realize is related, which again is very similar to The Friends of Eddie Coyle and The Town. Viewers see a woman, Lona McLane, coming out of a movie theater alone. She walks to her parked car, which won’t start. Paul Sheridan appears to offer assistance. Lona (and viewers) don’t know yet that Paul Sheridan is one of the detectives assigned to stake out Lona on the assumption that her boyfriend, Harry Wheeler, now identified as one of the bank robbers, will be back to see her—and will have the money from the heist with him. Paul falls for Lona, and they plot to keep the money for themselves.

I have a lot of trouble believing there was any chemistry between Paul Sheridan (played by Fred MacMurray) and Lona (Kim Novak). Maybe it’s just me: I can’t imagine that someone like Lona would fall for Fred MacMurray. I can’t get past the actor in this role. Such an obstacle is a bit of a liability in a film that bases the detective’s downfall on the passion between the two leads. It just didn’t work for me, but that may not be true for other viewers. It’s hardly a reason not to recommend the film. I really enjoyed the story. The way that Pushover depicts how one police detective slides into corruption is an interesting take on a familiar noir story.

Another plot point bothered me a bit. Several detectives work shifts in the stakeout of Lona’s apartment. One of the detectives, Rick McAllister, imagines that he is falling in love with one of Lona’s neighbors, a woman he isn’t supposed to be watching—but he is. He does meet this neighbor in the apartment hallway one day, when she is being harassed by a man her roommate knows. The harasser takes her purse and won’t give it back unless she agrees to go out for a drink with him. McAllister hears her protests and intervenes, convincing the man—with an arm twist and a shove—to beat it. The woman, Ann Stewart, introduces herself and admires McAllister’s technique; she wonders aloud if she could learn it herself. McAllister tells her that it would be better to avoid that type in the first place.

McAllister is a detective: He should know that Stewart—that no one—has clairvoyant powers into the depths of other people’s characters. But it’s 1954 and blaming the victim, especially a female victim, may have been even more common in 1954 than it is today. It turns out, however, that McAllister’s own powers of observation fail him: One of the detectives working with him, Paul Sheridan, is scheming to steal the bank money for himself and Lona, the bank robber’s girlfriend. Pushover doesn’t make too much of this as a theme, but I noticed it.

Again, my reservations about Fred MacMurray and about the unaddressed theme described above do not prevent me from recommending the film. As I said, I really enjoyed the story. And the plot twists (Can Lona McLane trust Paul Sheridan? Is Lona the quintessential femme fatale?) held my interest enough that I saw the film twice. But I do wish Paul Sheridan had been played by another actor.

No comments:

Post a Comment