My last three articles were about Deadline-U.S.A., Scandal Sheet, and Assignment-Paris—all released in 1952 and all examples of newspaper noir. That is, all are stories about newspaper reporters and their work publishing the news of the day. I hadn’t planned on writing about newspaper noir three consecutive times, but because it has worked out that way, it seemed like a good opportunity to investigate newspaper noir, a subgenre of film noir, a little bit.
◊ Deadline-U.S.A., released March 14, 1952
◊ Scandal Sheet, released January 16, 1952
◊ Assignment-Paris, released September 4, 1952
I tried an online search for newspaper noir and didn’t find much information about this type of film. But I did find one article about journalism in noir at the website Heart of Noir. Click here to visit the site for more information.
Deadline-U.S.A., Scandal Sheet, and Assignment-Paris are certainly not the only films about newspapers and reporters. Heart of Noir lists many examples of newspaper noir, and it looks like I have more films noir to see. At Heart of Noir, the criterion for categorizing a film noir as a newspaper noir is simply that “[a]t least one character works in journalism.”
Although I am not a big fan of categories, as I have said/written many times before, I’d like to think that the one character and their work for a newspaper are not the only criteria that make a film a newspaper noir. The character and their newspaper work should at least be the main parts of the film’s narrative, which would thus include the newspaper and its one or more employees as vital parts of the story. So I would limit the category a little more: I wouldn’t call a film noir a newspaper noir if only one of the characters happened to work for a newspaper.
I realize that the designation of a film as newspaper noir (or even as film noir) is subjective. Fans have definite opinions—and that’s one of the things that makes writing about noir interesting for me.
And then there is the term newspaper noir trilogy, which is applied specifically to three of Fritz Lang’s films. I have already written about all three:
◊ The Blue Gardenia, released March 28, 1953
◊ While the City Sleeps, released May 16, 1956
◊ Beyond a Reasonable Doubt, released September 13, 1956
The Blue Gardenia explores the public’s appetite for sensational stories and a newspaper reporter’s willingness to pander to those appetites. In While the City Sleeps, a newspaper’s reporters learn of a serial killer terrorizing young women in New York City. The paper’s owner decides to create the position of executive director and give it to the person who learns the killer’s identity first, thus setting up a fierce competition and putting lives at risk.
A newspaper publisher in Beyond a Reasonable Doubt maintains that an innocent man can be arrested, convicted, and executed on circumstantial evidence alone. He nominates his future son-in-law to be the innocent suspect in his experiment that involves the very real crime of murder. The publisher’s plan is really an obstruction of justice and manipulation of public opinion and the justice system.
It isn’t uncommon for film noir to feature newspaper reporters, and this makes sense. Reporters function much like private detectives and police investigators who search the dark and shadowy side of human nature for a living. Reporters search for the truth (not always true in noir, of course) and publish stories about what they find. But they also have to pay attention to what the public wants and is willing to pay for, and the tension between the two can sometimes get in the way of honesty and the pursuit of justice in the public arena.
This tension is part of the narrative in Scandal Sheet, although I would say that Mark Chapman, editor in chief at the New York Express and one of the main characters in the film, cares a lot less about the truth and a lot more about selling newspapers and increasing circulation. His newspaper sponsors publicity stunts that are also meant to increase sales and have nothing to do with a search for the truth and informing the public. His blatant manipulation of the public to make more money and sell more newspapers sounds like the modern version capitalism applied at times to social media and reality television.
Deadline U.-S.-A. is a film about the feared decline of the free press in the United States. The villain this time is not a single person but the prevailing trend of corporate consolidation and its effect on newspapers and their ability to maintain their independence. This is another modern theme: Large corporations and people with a lot of money (and political connections) are controlling more and more markets when it comes to news in 2026.
Assignment-Paris is a bit different from Deadline-U.S.A. and Scandal Sheet. This time, the villain is the communist regime in Hungary and its clampdown on the press, both domestically and internationally. The hero is a lone foreign correspondent from the United States who wants to report the facts and is repeatedly blocked and persecuted for trying to do his job. He is successful in the end, but he pays for it with his health and almost with his life. Again, the theme is surprisingly modern.
All three films—Deadline-U.S.A., Scandal Sheet, and Assignment-Paris—are modern in their take on human nature and the news. The same can be said of Lang’s newspaper noir trilogy. The themes in newspaper noir are still relevant today, even though newspapers are not nearly as ubiquitous as they once were.
The three screenshots are from Assignment-Paris (1952), Deadline-U.S.A. (1952), and While the City Sleeps (1956), respectively.
No comments:
Post a Comment